Dwinda
Adrianto
ENGL
114 B
Sean
Pessin
04/22/2012
Power
Politics: A Predetermined Perseverance
The
notion of power has always been around since the early19th century, Charles
Darwin defined power as the basic notion that believes survival of the fittest is
the principal virtue that will ultimately ensure individual or group survival solely
based in the principal of natural selection. It justifies the realist argument that
“the strong shall devour the weak” as a natural order which governs our
universe. In the field of International relations, power falls into two distinct
categories: Soft Power and Hard Power, whereas soft power believes that
principle strength derives from an individual or a group’s ability to influence
others and hard power derives from an individual or groups ability to coerce or
dictate others to behave accordingly by establishing a rigid hierarchy (Kegley
36). This notion of power plays a dominant role throughout the Foundation series, throughout the series the Author Isaac
Asimov seems to focus solely on how the Foundation managed to survive among
hostile neighbors despite having limited military capabilities. This paper will
focus on the earliest stages of the Foundation establishment which allowed it
to navigate through various crisis along the book, it is an undeniable fact
that the Foundations dominance and influence is a direct result of the
effectively early exercise of its soft and hard power Overall the Foundations
survival is heavily attributed by its effective manipulation of soft and hard
power
The Foundation series that falls
under the science fiction genre illustrates many deep political aspects that
are relevant in actual life especially in the fields of international relations
which explain specifically on how a state dominates the hostile environment
within the international level. The book proposes the notion that military
power is not the only means to become a dominant player in the galaxy but also
through the effective combination of leadership, technological innovation and
establishing a dominant influence. The foundation’s survival against all odds
is a result of the foundation's ability to effectively maneuver through its
barbaric surroundings by establishing a dominant presence within its periphery.
The story
revolves around the Galactic Empire and a prediction made by a man called Hari
Seldon with a background of psychohistory which predicted the inevitable fall
of the Empire. Seldons views were viewed as a severe offence and nonsensical by
the empire’s administrators which resulted on his immediate exile along with
all of his followers to a far and desolate planet in the far fringes
of the galaxy called Terminus. Here Seldon wishes to establish a
scientific haven in order to preserve humanity's achievement if the galaxy were
to fall in a period of barbarism after the empire's fall. From there on the
plot revolves around how does the foundation managed to survive while it is
surrounded by hostile natives which hopes to exploit and conquer the foundation
itself. Through the effective combination of technological supremacy and
effective diplomacy the Foundation quickly become one of the most influentially
powerful planets within the periphery rivaling that of the declining Galactic
Empire itself. The Foundation Series compromise out of three books: The
Foundation, Foundation and Empire and Second Foundation. The first book focuses
on how the foundation was established and how it became a dominant power within
its periphery, the Foundation and Empire focuses on the war between the
foundation and remnants of the Galactic Empire before being destroyed by a mind
controlling creature called “the mule”, the Second Foundation focuses on the
foundation’s success in catching the mule off guard and telepathically altered
his psyche and the search for the second foundation located in Trantor. This
paper will break down the role of power throughout the three foundation series
book which will be done by sections.
The deep political aspect is always
relevant as the book progresses. It describes the aspects of applied soft power
and hard power possessed by the foundation in which ensures its survival. Firstly,
through the analysis of soft power the book relates on how other planets
depended on the foundation's technological innovation for survival and how
the Foundation managed to establish a religious order centered within
Foundation. The hard power aspect would be the foundation's possession of
atomic energy which other planet feared as being atomic weapons. The
Effective manipulation of these two aspects of power ultimately led the
Foundation to become a dominant and influential player among its hostile
neighbors. Another political aspect which could be discussed would be the role
of the central government in shaping the foundations policy which relates to
external threat, where a constant conflict between a more pacifist government
and a more assertive government within the foundation is always prevalent. The
pacifists were people who believed that conflict should be the last measure in
dealing with external threat while the hardliners believed that the Foundation
should strengthen its military capabilities to deter possible aggressions.
However as it turns out the pacifist under the mayor Salvor Hardin were the one
who took control calling for other means either than war to deter possible
aggressors, this illustrates the idea that force is not the only possible
option to survive from external threats. This correlates with true events on
what we see happening in our own world and judging by the overall aspect
dominant throughout this book, Isaac Asimov must be inspired by actual events
the events on which the author draws its inspiration. The story's overall
suspense for me at least lies in the events unfolding when the foundation
faces would be aggressors and then later on deterring them
"peacefully". Overall this book has an overall plot where
many readers will find overwhelming with information, too fast paced and a sense
of neglect in the areas of character development. One would assume upon reading
the book that the characters the author made for this book only compliments the
overall plot, and generally speaking it is likely that the plot itself is
the story and the primary focus given the less amount of time the author
gave in describing and developing some of the numerous characters in the book
First, we
shall analyze the first book and how does power politics of play through the
foundations effective use of diplomacy. During the period when Terminus have
just been settled down by researchers whose sole aim is to finish the
Encyclopedia Galactica, the founders soon finds that the planet is scarce of
steel and aluminum and their primary supply comes from the empire itself which
is considered too far away while its sole survival is determined by a kingdom
called Anacreon which has the agenda to dominate Terminus itself. The
foundation is divided into two different factions first one calls for a more
pacifist approach towards aggressors by relying on the Empire for its
protection while it focuses solely on the completion of the Encyclopedia
Galactica this faction is led by Lewis Pirenne and the other faction calling
for the complete independence from the empire led by Salvor Hardin. It is
inevitable that the foundation will have to rely on the Anacreon for protection
and resources since the empire seems uninterested on providing safety for the
foundation from outside aggressors. However Anacreon wanted compensation in
exchange for ensuring the foundations protection among them being allowing
Anacreon to establish military bases in Terminus itself which doesn’t sit very
well with the faction that focuses solely in the development of the
encyclopedia. Hardin, thanks to his skillful diplomacy at first deters Anacreon
military base intentions by announcing that the foundation is in possession of
atomic energy which Anacreon has none of therefore intimidating Anacreon by the
possibility of the Foundation possessing advanced weaponry this is seen by the
look of surprise of Anselm Haut Rodric an envoy of the Anacreonian kingdom when
Hardin mentioned of the Foundations possession of atomic power.
One could
analyze this aspect of power by using the realist notion of “Hard Power” which
defines power derives from the capability to intimidate others (Viotti 15).
This notion can be observed in the field of international relations which
defines the relationship between two or more states based on distrust and
suspicion. If related with the issue we see in regards to the relationship
between the Foundation and Anacreon, it is clear that Anacreon fears the
possibility of Terminus possessing atomic energy which will not rule out the
possibility that the Foundation is also in possession of atomic weapons and
being able to us it at its disposal. What added to the fear of the Anacreonian
is that its own lack of similar power for its disposal, so in order for
Anacreon to annex Terminus as its territory it must be really careful or risk
possible destruction in the hands of atomic weapons. If we were to relate this phenomena
with actual events which justifies the validity of the hard power theory we can
clearly observe in such cases where countries who possesses atomic energy tend
to have the capabilities to develop atomic weapons tends to arouse fear of its
neighbors and tends to be treated carefully if they potentially posses such
capabilities this. Through this witty remark made by mayor Salvor Hardin, it
successfully asserted diplomatically that the Foundation is a force to be
reckoned with and will demand respect. Through the combination of the effective
use of diplomacy which is considered soft power and the use of coercive
intimidation which falls under the hard power category Terminus ensured its
survival as it goes through the first Seldon Crisis one could not argue that a
perfect combination of the foundations Soft Power and hard power ultimately
ensures its survival and independence from a foreign power in this case the
Anacreonians.
Through the effective use of
discreet intimidation masked as the willingness of the Foundation to agree with
Anacreonian proposal on establishing a military base within the foundation in
exchange for protection and resources, Mayor Hardin succeeded in stalling the
inevitable invasion of Anacreonian forces in Terminus. Mayor Hardin perceived
that cooperating with Anacreon is the only feasible alternative because due to
the Galactic Empire’s reluctance to help protect the Foundation from possible
aggressors and the Foundation’s relative isolation from other parts of the
empire, mayor Hardin also knew that the best way to avoid direct confrontation
with Anacreon is to pretend to cooperate with Anacreon and simultaneously
reaping the benefits of Anacreon providing for the Foundation’s security and
providing them with steel and aluminum. There’s no arguing that mayor Hardin is
well versed in the field of politics, and his ideas itself is not exclusively
exists in this particular science fiction series, Sun Tzu an ancient Chinese
war strategist mentioned “
For to win one
hundred victories in one hundred battles is not the acme of skill. To
subdue the enemy without fighting is the acme of skill”, therefore one must not
solely rely on direct confrontation with the enemy in order to win however
being able to win battle through the effective use of strategy is of the
extreme excellence.
It is an undeniable fact that when the foundation
is still at its weakest diplomacy plays an important role in ensuring the
Foundations survival. Diplomacy can be
defined as the art and practice of negotiations between different nations or
the skill of handling affairs without hostility (Nau 7). There are many aspects in soft power but for
this case example soft power is distinguished as “smart power” which can be
defined as a nation’s leadership capabilities in conducting diplomacy without
the excessive use of force (Nye). A correlation with the effective use of soft
power would be if it were not for Hardin’s policy in not resorting to force to
expel the Anacreonians, the Foundation will find itself destroyed because it
has no means for direct conflict with the Anacreonians at that time so Hardin
bought time for the Foundation to develop. Another indirect result of this
smart maneuver by Hardin is the fact that the foundation manages to develop
sophisticated technology under the Anacreonian protection that allowed the
Foundation to become a major power in the future. During the earliest times of
the Foundations establishment the Foundation finds itself lacking the basic
resources necessary to establish a respectable civilization and in this
vulnerable state the risk of facing an all out war with Anacreon is far too
great. By pretending to cooperate with Anacreon despite the pro encyclopedia
faction insistence on taking a more tougher role it reaps more benefit that it
would be from an all out war therefore biding the foundation time to develop
peacefully under Anacreon’s protection and when the Foundation slowly becomes
more sophisticated than Anacreon they will rebel and kick them out of their
planet once and for all. The point of this that through the effective
manipulation of soft power diplomacy achieved through effective leadership, the
Foundation managed to navigate the threat of direct Anacreonian assault without
deterring through the use of force.
It is evident that leadership plays an important
role in ensuring the foundations survival during Hardin’s period. Leadership
itself falls under the category of soft power where the ability or inability of
a particular state to project power outside its borders rests solely in the
individual leader’s leadership capabilities. Before Hari Seldon re emerges in
terminus after years of his death thanks to holographic projection to announce
what is called the Seldon Crisis: A prediction of events that will happen to
the Foundation within a particular period of time he mentions that the
Foundations will go through a turbulent period of time marked by the Galactic
Empire’s decline and the fall of its surroundings into a period of barbarism, I
personally believe that Hardin with his sheer combination of mastery in
politics, effective use of diplomacy and strategically thinking is the right
person to lead the foundation as it undergoes its early years of turbulent
periods marked by power struggle of the planets within the fringes of the
Galactic Empire.
Another case example of soft power execution
which could be observed throughout the book would be the Foundations effective
use of trade. The ability to influence the policies of other states or planets
in this case is through the foundations establishment of trade dependence
centered within the foundation. Trade dependence centered in the foundation
also plays a huge role in deterring would be aggressors to the Foundation. The
Foundation being a technologically superior among the less technology
sophisticated countries within its periphery made the Foundations survival
important for all the other planets that depended on the Foundations
technological capabilities and engineering capabilities. It is generally
believed that a nation would be reluctant to attack another nation if it risks
the threat of injuring itself economically (Nau 7) the Foundation is able to
assert control towards other planets policy through the dependence of other
planets through trade with the foundation. In the areas of political economy
trade plays a huge role in determining a nation’s soft power capability since
it is one of the fundamental aspect to assert control without the use of force.
No doubt the foundation gained tremendous benefits through the establishment of
a Foundation centered trade as a result of its technological innovation that
allowed it to dominate the system as less developed planets rely heavily on the
Foundations technological capabilities for its survival.
The greatest achievement the Foundation made in
ensuring that no planet dared to attack its territory is through the
establishment of a religious order based on technology centered within the
foundation itself with priests who happen to also be engineers which are
stationed in other planets, in reality this could be similar with the Vatican
centered Catholicism and Saudi Arabian centered Islamic world which plays a
dominant role in being the center of faith for millions of people. The same
argument also applies through the Foundation centered religious order, by
establishing a religious order the Foundation has managed to control the minds
of the people within its periphery, it’s an undeniable fact that faith plays a
huge role in determining people’s actions. Within the book the Anacreonians
tried a second attempt to occupy the Foundation but the attempt failed because
other planets condemned the invasion calling it sacrilegious. The Anacreonian
troops also are reluctant sacred ground since the Foundations religious order
has established dominant roots in other planets. The soft power nature of
religion lies in the fact that if you manage to control people’s minds and
perception you ultimately have the upper hand in the areas of diplomacy so it
could be considered another way of establishing a dominant influence.
Overall the foundation series being a science
fiction genre on itself, relates to actual real life possibilities of things relating
with the areas of possibilities on what could happen in the future. Being of
the science fiction genre the author Isaac Asimov has managed to tie the
significant plot throughout the book with the factual reality of inter- state relations.
In the case of the foundation series it is evident that there is a deep rooted
political aspect happening throughout the book on which this paper analyzes
with the use of theories within the field of international relations. In the
world of anarchy power plays an important role for survival and power itself
can be categorized as hard and soft power. It is clearly evident that like in
actual life, the Foundations survival is a result of the effective
manipulations of the aspects of power and the things which contributes to that
specific power respectively therefore in order to survive in a world where
according to Hobbes is complete anarchy where men devours other man is through
obtaining power and having the necessary capabilities to assert them.
Sources
Kegley,
Charles w. World Politics: Trends & Transformation. 9th edition.
Thompson Woodsworth Publishing 2008. Print. April 22 2012
Nau,
Henry. Perspectives On International Relations: Power, Intitutiona, Ideas. 3rd
eition. CQ Press Publishing. Print. April 22 2012
Nye,
Joseph. Foreign Policy Magazine April 2011. “The War On Soft Power”. Web. April
22 2012
Viotti,
Paul R. International Relations And World Politics: Security, Economy,
Identity. Prentice Hall Publishing. Print. April 22 2012